
Approximately 50 years ago, the west gate box-girder bridge in Melbourne, Australia collapsed under construction killing over 30 people in what is now widely regarded as Australia’s worst construction accidents ever. Prior to this failure, several other failures of box girder bridges were recorded. The first was the Fourth Danube bridge over the Danube river in Vienna Austria. This 426m long box girder bridge, in fact, did not actually collapse but was hanging in the air and appeared kink and distorted.
Next, was the Milford Haven bridge in Wales, also a box girder bridge with seven spans. While still under construction, on 2 june, 1970, one of it central spans suddenly buckled and collapsed leaving four fatalities. Subsequently, there were several other failures, infact two box girder bridges collapsed within the space of two months. However, out of all these failures, one stood out, the west gate bridge, it was the most catastrophic and had the highest fatality. (see featured image).
The West Gate Bridge
The west gate bridge in Melbourne Austraila had 8 lanes and was 2.6km long. It had 67m long concrete approach spans, and five continous steel box girders, totaling a span of 848m. The lengths of the box girder had trapezoidal Sections made up of three cells, supported by cables as they stretch over the Yarra River.
The design concept was made in the UK by Freeman, Fox & Associates Consulting – The same consultants on the british Milford Haven Bridge. When construction commenced on the West Gate in April 1968, the world was yet to even witness the first of the significant box girder collapse.
There were difficulties from the onset of the project, widespread labour strikes became recurrent such that the steel contractor infact had to be replaced in early 1970 for delays. Shortly after, came the news of the first collapse, Millford Haven, 2000km away in Wales. Interestingly, Millword Haven was designed by the same design company as the West-gate bridge. Freeman, Fox & Partners is on record to have thought the failure to be a once in a lifetime occurrence, although they undertook steps to improve the West Gate Work. This was true, considering the fact that a different construction method was adopted – the free cantilering erection method. However investigation into the failure later proved the chosen method of construction was in fact detrimental.
Causes of Failure
The contractor fabricated half of each span on the field, just imagine cutting each span down its length, leaving two spans of half-width. In addition, each of these half-spans was then raised up 50m in the air and slide into place (Figure 1). The contractor thus halved the load for each lift-although doubling the number of lifts. By the time of the Milford Haven collapse, the east and west spans of the West Gate Bridge, each 112m long, were ready for erection. Then, one of the eastern half-spans developed a problem. It was built but when it was separated at ground level from its temporary braces, it suddenly developed a buckle on the top free flange – the flange that would pass down the centerline of the bridge when attached to the other half-span.

The buckle occurred because of the decision to lift each half-span separately. While the free flange was stiffened longitudinally and transversally, there was a problem with both sets of stiffeners (Figure 2). The transverse stiffeners didn’t have the necessary stiffness to restrain the longitudinal stiffeners, and this lack of restraint resulted in the longitudinal stiffeners and it bridged a gap of 318mm between the points where one stiffener ended and the other began. Additionally, the plate was set off from the stiffeners, and this eccentricity induced, coupled with a smaller splice plate region and the distance between the stiffeners, produced a point of weakness in the longitudinal stiffeners at every joint.

So, there was a buckle in the flange plate now, but instead of lowering the span back onto its brackets and removing the buckle when it was still at ground level, the decision was made to continue with the lift and then attempt to remove the buckle when the span was in its final position – at a height of 50 m. But this buckle was significant – 380mm – and once the span was placed in position, there was no way it could be unloaded. Despite all of this, the lift went ahead.
Now they were faced with the dilemma of straightening the buckle at a height of 50m above ground. The decision was to remove the bolts from some of the transverse splices in the top flange, practically removing the flanges ability to resist compression stresses. Thus, with the stresses relieved, they could let the plates slide over each other and then flatten out the buckle. Once flattened, new holes were drilled or existing holes were widened in the overlapping plates, and new bolts installed¹.
Attention then turned to the western span. Something had to be done before the buckling would happen. They decided to stiffen the flange itself with an extra longitudinal stiffener, and they also added cross beams running diagonally from the top free flange back to the bottom flange. The arrangement indeed worked and buckling was avoided. However, when they opted to connect both spans, they noticed a vertical gap of 115mm between them. Whilst they were faced with the same issue in the eastern span, they were able to remove it with the help of a hydraulic jack. But in the case of the western span, the 115mm gap was to much a distance for the jack to close. So, they opted to place large concrete blocks weighing about 51tonnes on one half of the span to close the gap. This worked and the gap was closed. However, after some time the entire upper flange suddenly buckled – this was what they’ve been trying to prevent all along. While there was sufficient capacity to prevent buckling during the lift, the extra loading from the 51 tonnes concrete block was to much load on the girder.
Left with no further choice, they had to consider the method used to fix the eastern gate. However, there was a significant difference between the eastern and western spans. Due to the additional load from the 51 tonnes concrete block on the western span, the buckling was significantly higher than that of the eastern span. As they began to remove bolts, the stresses in the remaining parts began to increase, with every bolt removal the stress increased, and there was a reduction in the section net area. A total of 37 bolts were removed, by then the bridge could take no more, the net section failed and the remaining bolts sheared. A mechanism has ensued (Figure 3).

The left hand of the span started to drop while the load shifted to the right hand half since it was partially connected. The the entire span collapsed 50m to the ground killing 35 people (Figure 4).

Lessons from Failure
As with all structural failures, the collapse spark global outrage and there was now very pressing need for answers. What followed was an intense period of lessons and learnings in bridge design. The need for answers became extremely urgent. Rightly so because in the U.K alone 49 steel box girders were already in the construction stages with another 30 in the design stage³.
To say that the events from 1969 up until 1973 were an unprecedented series of bridge collapse would almost be an understatement. Five box girder bridge failures resulting in the death of 56 people have already occured. The rapid collapse of the bridges was stark. The Fourth Danube bridge in November 1969, followed by Milford Haven seven months later, followed by the West Gate bridge four months later, followed by the Rhine river bridge 13 months later and lastly the Zeulenroda bridge 21 months later.
These failures inadvertently showcased how difficult it is to undertake fast and comprehensive investigations that can be disseminated back into the profession to arrest a flow of failures. Because, even though in the light of the Millford collapse, the design team took steps to improve the West Gate bridge, this wasn’t enough to arrest an endemic misunderstanding of bridges built from thin steel plates.
Investigation on the Fourth Danube bridge revealed that the bridge failed largely due to temperature effects¹. During its construction, both sides of the centre span cantilevered towards one another. On the afternoon of 6 November 1969, the two cantilevers met in the middle and were joined. But the warm temperatures during the afternoon had caused the spans to deflect more and they had to be shortened by 15mm at the top. Then in the evening, the temperature dropped, which placed the top flange in tension. As the temperature drop continued, tension in the top flange increased, which then placed the entire bottom flange in compression. Sadly, the original plan was to lower the two inner supports once the cantilevers had been joined, which would have prevented this behaviour, but it had been decided to undertake this lowering the following day.)
The Milford investigation team revealed that Milford collapse was initiated by an inadequatly stiffened diaphragm¹. Designers at the time were unaware of this issue, this is evident in the fact that the design codes at the time reflected a lack of this knowledge.
The west gate collapsed on the other hand happened due to a variety of issues as explained in the preceding sections. But on top of the list, was the lack of understanding of the behaviour of stiffening plates. The Rhine river bridge collapse was caused by the buckling of its compression flange halfway, whilst the zeulenroda bridge collapsed due to insufficient flange plates and longitudinal stiffners.
In the wake of this events and after four known failures. What followed was a Royal commission in Australia into the West Gate Bridge failure and the other bridge failures. The committee after investigations and research produced an interim report with new set of design rules and workmanship guidance. Efforts of this research went into practice, with existing bridges strengthened.
It is 50 years now and to a great extent, the technical issues have been learnt, and the underlying issues are now fully addressed by modern design codes. But has any ethical lessons been learnt, maybe or maybe not. This days bridge failures occur far to regularly, most commonly during construction. Usually there are technical issues and this needs to be understood and cannot be overlooked. However, in almost every case it’s almost always the ethical and procedural factors that hold the answer to the reason why the failure could not be averted.
For instance, in the case of the Fourth Danube bridge the lowering of the inner support could’ve being done much earlier but instead it was postponed for the next day. Legend has it, that ” never put off until tommorow what can be done today”. The consequence of not lowering the inner supports on time resulted in their inability to salvage the situation. Sir Alec Merrison said in presenting the Committee’s conclusions in 1973: “No amount of writing of design codes and writing of contracts can in the end be guaranteed to prevent the results of stupidity, carelessness or incompetence. But one can do a great deal to discourage these vices and that must be done.”
In conclusion, failures will always be a part of human endeavour because humans are part of it. Structural engineering like all other professions cannot really advance without it failures³. This is a sad reality. The testing of design assumptions and methods happen in real world and public view, sometimes with tragic consequences.
Ensuring that these lessons are learnt as they were with the stories of the box girder bridges will certainly not bring back the dead or take the pain left behind by failures away. However, engineers can learn from it in this age of generational amnesia where younger engineers are likely to dismiss these stories as interesting but irrelevant and inapplicable.
Also, See: The Collapse of the Malahide Viaduct
References
1. State of Victoria, West Gate Bridge Royal Commission (1971) Report of Royal Commission into the failure of West Gate Bridge [Online]
2. Merrison Committee (1973) Inquiry into the basis of design and method of erection of steel-box girder bridges, London: HMSO
3. Brady S. (2016) West Gate Bridge collapse – he story of the box girders. The Structural Engineer, 94 (10), pp. 26–28.
Thank You, Kindly Share this Post
Useful topic
stromectol for humans
buy modafinil online fast shipping
antabuse over the counter uk
viagra 100 mg price in india
30-day cialis
canada pharmacy 24h
buy clomid without a prescription
cialis online drugstore
ivermectin online
purchase stromectol online
stromectol coronavirus
stromectol online
ivermectin tablet 1mg
ivermectin 1
stromectol for humans
ivermectin 50ml
ivermectin 2mg
ivermectin usa
stromectol tablets for humans
ivermectin 250ml
ivermectin 3 mg tablet dosage
ivermectin over the counter canada
ivermectin 0.5%
ivermectin 200 mcg
stromectol price uk
ivermectin 3mg tablets
stromectol for humans
buy stromectol
stromectol order online
stromectol order
ivermectin 5ml
stromectol price uk
generic stromectol
cost of ivermectin cream
ivermectin ireland
generic ivermectin cream
ivermectin 0.1 uk
purchase ivermectin
En son web haberleri gerçek zamanlı
beste vertaalsite
redmi note 8 pro review
ver frozen 2 online
how to change time format in windows 10
najlepsze czcionki
stromectol where to buy
marketplace facebook aanzetten
juego de tronos temporada 8 capitulo 2
ivermectin brand
shang-chi
noreply
videobewerkingssoftware
ivermectin 3 mg tabs
70 usd to ils
ยามเย็น เนื้อเพลง
tai fortnite
ivermectin buy
nicole maines
קוויזיז
slå samman pdf
merge cells in word
beda avast premier dan internet security
アイアンマン死亡
nfqvth jykfqy
pareto chart in excel
papás animados
các framework php phổ biến
airpod หาย
the handmaids tale season 2 episode 13
リックアンドモーティ シーズン4
emolo
280 euro
whateverhappens/kn
vsync
En son web haberleri gerçek zamanlı
stromectol australia
ian somerhalder
justin h. min
marvel chronologie
ขนาดเฟสบุ๊ค
youtubeเป็นmp3
μtorrent アンインストール
vivoactive
ejemplos de infografías
zegarek orlando
12 dollar
libreoffice review
ivermectin for humans
hola siri
sasha morali
nokia 225 4g
ivermectin cost uk
フリーポートマクモラン
kapitan ameryka postać grana przez
stromectol uk
เว็บเบราเซอร์
discord auf ps4
najbliższa pełnia
ps4 コミュニティ
คอร์ด เพลง สาว เทคนิค
новые смайлики для ватсапа
la casa de papel
kristen bell películas y programas de televisión
hvordan tager man screenshot på mac
area de un trapezoide
ivermectin 4000 mcg
lector pdf gratis
cpabien
thermomix lidl
msi afterburner descargar
de millas a kilometros
resize image without losing quality
south park temporada 23
baritt diode
nba live stream
julia fox
курт энгл
deslizar
корреляция пирсона pandas
ли су гын
מניית nio
บา เยิ ร์ น อาร์เซนอล
keith sapsford
agentes de shield temporada 7
nota musical simbolo
stromectol pill
hashimotos sjukdom
beste tablet op dit moment
hane çikolata
クレイヴン・ザ・ハンター
dojutsu
hafa
pt transpacific finance
tutanota
pubg lite no esta disponible en tu region
<a href="https://www.hebergementwebs.com/ajax-page-articledesc.php?fid=5549945
playstation plus giugno 2019
combler synonyme
thepiratebay.com
bob newby
bästa robotdammsugaren
btc usd
best massage gun 2020
zoom ホワイトボード
optag skærm mac
linea del tiempo en power point
comment faire une capture décran mac
wmi provider host
where can i buy stromectol
cheyenne jackson
utorrent web
goedkope monitor
equalizer apo
jumanji 3 release date
danny pino
ekiten
memoji
flr token price
velodyne aktie
plex naming convention
super bowl kick off time uk
voorraad ps5
splunk là gì
hide scrollbar css
express vpn
sky high 2
grub
ตัวการ์ตูนวิทยาศาสตร์
ivermectin stromectol
ivermectin 9 mg tablet
stromectol how much it cost
как кататься на коньках задом
aviseringar chrome
duckduckgo vs google
matt cornett
snowpiercer netflix
heroquest
enregistrer video facebook
ivermectin 4 mg
what is ioc in spring
eegay
cernobil nerede
idei de afaceri
ftp firefox
stromectol pill
buy ivermectin uk
studio ghibli filmer produsert
obs studio come funziona
フランシスガヌー
playstation gavekort
כריסטינה ריצי
código ascii
carvana aktie
are apple watches waterproof
קוולטריקס
фалаут 5
como se usa instagram
any pdf to dwg converter online
ivermectin 50ml
ivermectin 4
ntuser.dat
tipos de transformadores
obiektywy nikon
dreepy evolution
freebitco
windows hello
meanjs
delete badoo account
מיינט
netflix konto
trò chơi roblox
samuel johnson sitater
discord bold text
programa para escanear
facetime android
โทรศัพท์ที่ดีที่สุด
laura haddock filmler ve tv şovları
filmy netflix 2021
why do we hiccup
jumanji 3
the boys diễn viên
hbo dar de baja
populære google-doodle spil
mechagodzilla
broadway là gì
samsung galaxy s10e black friday
penceredeki kadın
ezimba
プラウラー スパイダーマン
stromectol in canada
dns orange
password pc dimenticata windows 10
iptv pirata
hdr que es
stromectol price uk
bon siman
ตัดพื้นหลัง photoshop
alternative a teamviewer
delete repository github
emily blunt peliculas
stromectol xr
whatsapp via computer
telefoni migliori
eric andre
net::err_connection_reset
chrome opdatering
סלטיקס נגד ויזארדס
suya dayanıklı telefonlar
billig internett
tadalafil soft gel capsule
harlan coben netflix
hình nền sách
מירוץ סוסים ווינר
หุ้น nio
how to delete paypal account
star trek discovery reparto
radar yr
pinterest nasıl kullanılır
openshot video editor review
pomodoro metoden
mr melk
pinceles para illustrator
stress test pc
bright 2
första telefonen
donde estan las atrevidas
vlog คือ
paulette gebara
ps plus maggio 2020
one punch man ล่าสุด
mmorpg top
cách chơi pokemon ruby
black panther distribution
breedbeeld monitor
สรรพากร ยื่น แบบ
membuat sidebar dengan bootstrap
apo equalizer
pdf24 creator
beste filmer på netflix
new amsterdam seizoen 3 net 5
xbox all access
viagra 8000mg
nasıl arkadaş edinilir
gute science fiction filme
サノス デッドプール
discord status
mockup logo free
img html
samsung tv 43 tommer
como hacer una revista digital
what is bootloader
hokazo
yonca biçme makinesi
177013
tadalafil 20mg from india
nextfpv
contoh buletin
neurovetenskap
générateur de slogan
nadie sabe nada temporada 7
портфолиобокс
how to host on twitch
qled 55 pollici
sildenafil citrate tablets
robert kirkman
motosi̇klet
halo 5 guardians pc
รูป วาด กระต่าย
177013
finpecia tablets online
cĺassifica serie a
provigil south africa
greenshot
תואר ראשון במדעי המחשב
rick und morty bs.to
phim dieu chung minh chua biet
generic cialis for sale
cialis daily use 5mg – buy cialis from canada online buy tadalafil online without a prescription
signal 使い方
ワンパンマン 141
upgrade imdb
beste horrorfilms 2020
tadalafil 20mg daily
hydroxychloroquine sulfate
appleid.apple.cơm
aoc cu34g2x/bk
markedskalender
admiral thrawn
spring ioc container
miglior processore
list of online pharmacies
playstation plus märz 2019
aquaman 2 cast
frankrike portugal
strongest anime character
i love rolki
nyu caramel
how to buy modafinil in australia
cialis 5 mg daily – 5 cialis buy black cialis online
virginwines.com.au
fear walking dead
nsfw คือ
mua webcam
castlevania sezon 3
אסימפטומטי
best 15 inch laptop
watch love actually online free
united states tadalafil
samsung connect box
youtube ads cost
how to get subtitles on amazon prime
dalhousie implemented the doctrine of
imac 2019
ms project tutorial
hướng dẫn chơi diablo 3
homelander
ดู walking dead season 10
the tick cast
firefox monitor
starlink satellitterne
gpu stress test
google logo history
ru persoonlijk rooster
alita 2
zencastr
tạo form đăng ký thành viên trong wordpress
modelo scor
ivermectin price uk
филми 7
multiplos de 24
stromectol covid
ipados リリース日
how does twitter work
can you put neosporin on a dog
gaveideer til mor
virgin galactic 株価
cheyenne jackson
young justice temporada 3
shaders minecraft
giochi anime
top psp games
greys anatomy ctv
דורסי
algoritmo tiktok
formulieren google
negrita en html
green goblin actor
david castañeda
brugte tablets
オウムアムア 宇宙船
i love rolki
sanna meira
สีปูนเปลือย
yggtorrent
pareto chart excel
active transducer
error 0x80004005
vpn tercepat 2020
cialis australia pharmacy
snapchat سناب شات
характеристики моего пк
skeet ulrich
discord change password
john krasinski filmler ve tv şovları
roku vs chromecast
sildenafil 100mg uk paypal
tokenizm
gjenopprette iphone
f1 live
อัจฉริยะผู้สูญเสียศักยภาพ
antabuse for sale online
margin vs padding
michael burry
best buy aktie
til reddit
diablo 4 date de sortie
forgot instagram password
herobrine
tadalafil from mexico
fermer compte hotmail
google nol
zielony południk
ciyaaraha maanta
attack on titan personaggi
pasar de wav a mp3
nightflyers review
borderlando
icon địa chỉ vector
imparare java
hydroxychloroquine sulfate tab 200 mg
chrome full screen
kalibrera tv
viagra price comparison – sildenafil soft gel capsule sildenafil 100mg uk cheapest
classified easter egg
וומבלי בט
pokemon mạnh nhất thế giới
сири онлайн
thanos finger snap
action arcelor
fullmetal alchemist: brotherhood
sophie turner películas y programas de televisión
phim netflix đáng xem
windows 10 battery icon missing
ebay riepilogo
park bo-young phim và chương trình truyền hình
my call papildymas
ราคาหุ้นba
constitutioneel recht
price viagra 100mg – brand viagra without prescription sildenafil cheapest price uk
westworld online
how to turn off restricted mode on youtube
concatenar excel
mario casas filmler ve tv şovları
tecla retroceso
thuần túy là gì
wolfhound
giochi ps plus agosto 2019
soạn bài ngắm trăng tuthienbao
halo infinity
anatoly moskvin
リッチーポート
penghitungan suara luar negeri
gravitasjonskraft
tadalafil 2.5 mg daily
caricaturas de disney
tiger 3d chrome
como compartir pantalla en discord
nikolas ajagu
แปลงเพลงyoutube เป็น mp3
the ritual monster
pave the way for nghĩa là gì
ipe oppo
kablosuz gamepad
classification of data mining systems
can dogs eat raspberries
penghitungan suara luar negeri
mvi̇
numeri da stampare in bianco e nero
stromectol ivermectin tablets
prisma rectangular caras vertices y aristas
cara menggunakan trello
ecualizador para pc
extra torrent
error 522
punkbuster services
samsung one connect
tilfeldig engelsk
meilleur processeur
vw aktier
ps5 kaufen gamestop
sanipiù
gpuz
the ballad of buster scruggs explained
コム キャスト 株価
araña para pintar
benedict wong
george clooney películas y programas de televisión
ps5 disponible
what does nvm mean
dyte.se
como poner una imagen de fondo en power point
deagostini ru
pagerduty aktie
youtubeเป็นmp3
instagram analiz
wordpress taşıma
sailor moon
cillian murphy filmler ve tv şovları
sildenafil uk cheapest
ios ダウングレード
no mans sky ртуть
dyson rabatt
apple music pris
tadalafil 25 mg capsule
trainingsmasker
apostol pelicula
eleven stranger things
order viagra from mexico
11900k
tebak makanan
lune carlsen
amd com
0x80004005
giochi cross platform
misure banner yt
sildenafil 50 mg best price
насим педрад
eliminare telegram
strongest anime characters
moto gp transmisja
フロント ランニング
casper matras
avast free antivirus review
musikk streaming
cuadro de texto
quarterback là gì
robin ruth
steve carell film dan acara tv
how to delete multiple contacts in iphone
ppc interview questions
stranger things distribution
שיקוף מסך
iphone geen geluid bij bellen
model kasur bayi dan harganya
s21 מחיר
eddie murphy phim và chương trình truyền hình
spadajace gwiazdy kwiecien
horrory 2021
piratebay.org
untweeps
pop culture là gì
skracanie linków bitly
emmy raver-lampman
canadian pharmacy modafinil
gpu stress test
buy cialis online pharmacy – tadalafil from india to usa tadalafil drug generic drug
nikola azioni
cialis tablets australia – tadalafil dosage 40 mg cialis 100mg india
redwood pesisir
garmin forerunner 955
diablo 2
kindle offerta
ingeso
fond décran windows 10
go ride 80pro
cc biler
discord bold text
sildenafil 10 mg price
f1tv
ygg torent
linda perry
uninstall windows defender
cause effect graphing
giudice amy finale
פלקון
que veut dire lol
isomorfismo
text overlay facebook
txaa
buy tadalafil mexico online
porno interi
repel là gì
cillian murphy películas y programas de televisión
cialis 5mg for daily use
legacies temporada 3
best psp games
zoloft brand coupon
what is url blacklist
buy tamoxifen usa
virtuell klem
кем был джордж флойд
the walking dead 10
как вырезать круг в фотошопе
meningitis symptomer
profilowe na steam
ivermectin 3mg tab
iastoricon
how to delete roblox account
アバスト クリーンアップ
99 euro
node red là gì
serif affinity
subverse игра
kuya software
ทรงผมงานแต่ง
sony tv 55 tommer
cheapest cialis us
0xc00000e9
cheap viagra online fast delivery
red dead redemption 2 dlc
ou trouver une ps5
nvm
streaming f1
eufemismer
najmniejszy ptak
reboelje
seo proffs
menggeneralisasi
gmail prisijungimas