For some months now, we’ve discussed some of the many structural failures to have occurred in recent history and the importance of learning from the devastating effect that they bring. At the backdrop of each failure, were indeed great lessons to be learnt. In the case of the Hartford Civic-centre roof collapse the dangers of overconfidence and impulsively keeping faith in the output of software packages was the hallmark of the lessons learnt. The collapse of the Hyatt Regency walkways in Kansas Missouri raised and answered questions about engineering ethics. While the partial collapse of the Malahide, viaduct highlighted the factor of corporate memory loss.
We can always argue, legitimately, that engineering as a subject is the study of engineering failures or at the very least, a consideration of how to avoid failures. Rightly so, our biggest creations and innovations came from the lessons we learnt from failures. However, to demonstrate that lessons were indeed learnt from failures is to avoid future recurrence. We’ve talked about and still talking about learning from other peoples failures, but how easy it is to learn from these failures when we’re not directly involved?. Do the negative emotions they generate compel us to actually embrace learning or do they instead cloud our learning, replacing objectivity with subjectivity?. Or do we just want to forget, put the failure behind us, with the learning process relegated to a mere secondary consideration?.
Your guess is not as good as mine, the answers to these questions are not as straightforward as you’d think, but we can gain some insight from the research carried out by Dean Shepherd and his team at Indiana University USA. The team was interested in the response of different individuals to failures and project termination, the negative emotion generated and the impact on their ability to move from a project to another as well as their commitments to the company. More importantly, the team wanted to find out whether the negative emotion affected an individuals ability to learn lessons as to why the project failed and terminated. Or were these lessons simply lost?.
The team set out to conduct the study on research scientists and engineers. The study showed that for a research scientist, the negative emotion showed when a project failed/terminated were powerful and had a strong interference on learning. But interestingly the reverse was the case with engineers, they found that engineers deal with failures in a very different way.
The Scientist Mindset
The team’s research began with the research scientists from different research institutes in Germany. They interviewed the scientists, discussed recently terminated projects, how the scientists felt about them, what they learned, and what they would do differently next time around. They even returned to participants at later dates to ascertain whether their feelings had changed over time and whether or not more time for reflection had given them more insight into what went wrong.
Previous studies had found that many research scientists experience feelings of distress due to project termination. Many had committed to projects on a personal level, and the loss of time and energy that went into the terminated projects upset them. For many, these projects had become part of their identity, and without them, some scientists questioned who they truly were.
Shepherd’s research was comprehensive, and we can only cover a number of the key findings. Some are predictable, some are surprising. The study found that, as a result of these feelings of distress, many scientists felt less committed to the company’s goals. The good news was, however, that distance from the failed project – in terms of time – did indeed heal wounds, and resulted in an opportunity for reflection and learning.
The Engineer’s Mindset
With the engineers came the immediate question of do we learn more when a failing project is nipped in the bud quickly or is it better for the project to drag out slowly, with the entire project team subjected to what is known as creeping death?.
Conventional wisdom – from the perspective of the individual doing the terminating – argues in favour of the speedy termination of failing projects. The logic goes something like this: put measurement parameters in place to measure project success; if the project is failing, try and assess why; and if the issues cannot be fixed, then terminate it. The key advantage of this approach is the ability to reassign internal resources (namely, people) from the failing project to other more favourable projects.
Shepherd team set out to find out whether this conventional wisdom as we call it really applied to people working on a project in contrast to those doing the terminating. Do quick terminations provide an opportunity to learn any lessons from what went wrong and allow them to articulate what should be done differently next time?. For this study, the team turned their attention to the engineers. They selected engineers in the industry as well as those in education and research from across four divisions in an international company. Eight failed projects were examined, and engineers were interviewed, generally in person, over a significant period of time to ascertain how they responded to the failed projects.
Things immediately got interesting as the team found out that the engineers unlike the scientist generally never showed any negative emotion to failure/termination as long as it was done timely. Of all engineers interviewed only a few were a little bit upset and even for them it was more of what transpired after the termination than the termination itself.
The question that now comes to mind is, why were the engineers not reacting to project termination the way the scientist did?. The team found out that, whilst the scientist were pissed with the fact that they couldn’t achieve their project outcome the engineers only became upset when they were unable to continue contributing their engineering know-how. In order words engineers involved with failing projects were quickly redeployed to new projects allowing them to continue dispensing their engineering knowledge. With the new project came a new technical challenge, minimal negative emotions, and thus satisfaction. Whereas engineers involved with failing projects where termination was delayed did show negative emotions. But this was not the result of the termination itself but a failure to terminate in a timely manner resulting in their inability to deploy their engineering know-how into more worthwhile projects.
Extrapolating these findings to structural engineers suggest that as engineers, we pay more importance to the process of engineering more than the outcome it brings. I leave this to you to decide whether such an extrapolation is even reasonable. Well, I’m certain that, the fact that the engineering process can become more important than the engineering outcome is what we’ve seen several times- even with structural failures.
Effective Learning in Engineering
To minimize negative emotions for engineers, this research teaches us to terminate failing projects very quickly but there is a sting in the tail – minimizing negative emotion invariably limits our ability to learn.
For scientists, their negative emotion compromised their learning ability, but for engineers involved with failing projects terminated quickly the lack of negative emotions impaired the ability to learn because they were redeployed to new projects. These engineers had neither the time nor the inclination to learn lessons from previous projects, they were already too invested in the present challenges faced on new projects. However, the engineers caught in the projects experiencing creeping death experienced negative emotions born out of the frustration of not being able to move on to new projects. While these negative emotions interfered with the scientists’ learning, they actually drove the engineers learning. Out of frustration, these engineers strove to understand why their projects were failing. This search for understanding essentially became the engineers’ new project. For those involved in creeping death projects, the engineers said they had understood so much more about why their projects failed, and how they were able to take this learning and apply it to future projects. The time provided by creeping death, along with the negative emotions it generated, provided the necessary conditions for effective learning. Such reflection did not occur when the engineer was simply redeployed.
In the context of structural failures, even those beyond the far-reaching devastating loss of lives, lessons must always be learnt. Lessons learnt are often divided into technical and non-technical. Think of the technical lessons as the many code formulations and amendments. The Non-technical
lessons have to do with ethical, human/procedural factors. From all indications, it appears that the technical lessons are always learnt and put into practice however, the non-technical lessons are rarely learnt. There seems to be an endemic level of generational amnesia on this level. For example, in the light of the Hartford Civic-Centre roof collapse, one would naturally expect the modern engineer to have learnt enough lessons to maintain a healthy scepticism and not blindly keep faith in his own analysis result, not even when results are clearly wrong. But, unfortunately, the reverse continues to be the case.
This situation is far worse and even more complicated in developing countries like Nigeria where regulation is treated with levity. In an atmosphere where quackery is allowed to strive and where there is almost no consequence for failure and stark incompetence, you can certainly tell that there can’t be any negative emotion towards structural failures nor will there be any lesson learnt. It is important to identify causes of structural failures and the lessons to be learnt from them but it’s even more important to actually manifest those lessons learnt by putting them to work. As highlighted in the introductory aspect of this article, the primary reason for discussing engineering failures is to learn the lessons in order to forestall a future recurrence.
Those who cannot remember the past are destined to repeat it.
In conclusion, there is an entertaining line that goes something like “good decisions are a result of experience, but the experience is the result of poor decisions”. In the light of this research, we can tweak the line to read that “experience is the result of poor decisions, coupled with pain and time for reflection”. It appears that for engineers like ourselves, some pain is indeed gain. We really are a weird bunch.
Also see: Lessons from the Story of the Box Girders
References
1) Shepherd D. A., Patzelt H., Williams T. A. and Warnecke D. (2014) ‘How does project termination impact project team members? Rapid termination, “creeping death”, and learning from failure’, J. Manage. Stud., 51 (4), pp. 513–546 (Assesed July 2021).
2) Sean Brady (2015) How engineers learn from failures: Professional Guidance Notes, The
Structural Engineer. (Assessed July 2021).
Thank you for reading this post, kindly share it!
Its such as you read my mind! You seem to grasp a lot approximately this, such as you wrote the book in it or something.
I believe that you could do with some percent to pressure the message house a little bit, but other than that, that is great blog.
A fantastic read. I’ll certainly be back.
ventolin 100 prix ventolin generics side effects of overdose of ventolin
ventolin expectorant philippines ventolin generic release date ventolin cena refundacja
how to use a ventolin inhaler buy ventolin online pharmacological class of ventolin
salamol cfc-free inhaler vs ventolin nombre generico de ventolin ventolin ve pulmicort kullanД±mД±
ventolin inhaler and anxiety can you buy ventolin over the counter in uk obat ventolin inhaler salbutamol
can ventolin make you high buy ventolin inhaler spain ventolin druk gedrag
ventolin syrup infants buy ventolin online canada ventolin evohaler price uk
bijsluiter ventolin inhaler where to buy ventolin in singapore what are ventolin inhalers used for
can you get high on ventolin can you buy ventolin over the counter in portugal ventolin hfa india
ventolin inhaler dose for infants ventolin expectorant generic name cuando se usa el ventolin
diferencias entre atrovent y ventolin can i buy ventolin over the counter in spain ventolin dosage pediatrics
ventolin dose and frequency buy ventolin nebules online overuse of ventolin hfa
czy można kupić ventolin bez recepty buy blue ventolin inhaler ventolin hfa drug interactions
viagra and ritonavir how soon viagra take effect pillola viagra wikipedia
tamil viagra buy viagra in sydney australia nizagara vs viagra
viagra fast acting is it good to take viagra viagra ceguera
best price viagra us viagra wikipedia indonesia wat gebeurt er als vrouwen viagra nemen
can u take xanax with viagra red and black chinese viagra what happens snort viagra
what is the best viagra uk when we take viagra wanneer helpt viagra
is viagra used to treat pulmonary hypertension reviews buying viagra online generic viagra online 25mg
chest tightness viagra taking nitroglycerin and viagra buy viagra online india amazon
when will viagra work pharma apotheke viagra impotence after viagra
posso beber tomando viagra viagraxif can i take bystolic with viagra
harga viagra adalah viagra in my 30s can you get a sample of viagra
proper usage of viagra lizenz viagra venta viagra santa fe
mali oglasi viagra reviews buying viagra online how to get viagra young
wit product van viagra viagraxif viagra till kvinnor
dba viagra viagra kapszula viagra origine nome
can you slip someone viagra harga viagra 25mg viagra results pics
viagra yeux viagraxif indapamide and viagra
viagra revolution grapefruit drug interactions viagra viagra verkauf strafbar
how to get viagra on nhs prescription grapefruit drug interactions viagra how good is herbal viagra
viagra virker ikke what happens if i take half viagra viagra punta cana
cheap tadalafil cialis soft tabs purchase cialis
order viagra online overnight is it good to take viagra who should have viagra
viagra apa fungsinya 27 year old on viagra viagra while trying to get pregnant
viagra west midlands vitamin shoppe herbal viagra hur mycket viagra ska man ta
why is viagra prescription only viagra clock ebay when to take my viagra
cialis reviews cialis 5mg cheapest cialis
what is best viagra or cialis how quickly will viagra work safe meds viagra
fox news female viagra viagra alternative malaysia viagra ed infarto
extreme peptides viagra viagra finland what is best time to take viagra
why viagra no longer works viagra cialis kaina viagra avantage inconvenient
can you take viagra and amlodipine buying generic viagra in mexico originele viagra bestellen
online order viagra viagra jelly viagra prices
whats the ingredients in viagra viagra order online canada prescription viagra ireland
watermelon is powerful than viagra viagra cafeine issues with viagra
viagra solubility what happens snort viagra viagra pil schadelijk
free viagra samples buy cheap viagra online price of viagra
viagra traitement hypertension taking viagra with prozac viagra for pah
viagra ejaculate multiple times 75 mg of viagra health risks of taking viagra
cialis dose diaria tadalafil from india 5mg le cialis ca marche
sky pharmacy abusable prescription drugs canadian pharmacy king reviews
ooOO komentar pemakai cialis medshuku generic cialis online cialis brisbane
cialis coke tadalafil 5 mg liquid cialis homebrew
kako prepoznati original cialis tadalafil online with out prescription when does cialis go generic in us
buy cialis online italy 5 mg cialis usual dose cialis
most commonly abused prescription drugs heb online pharmacy canadian pharmacy testosterone cypionate
diferencias entre viagra cialis levitra tadalafil generic where to buy cialis krafttraining
lilly pharmaceuticals cialis erectafil from india european cialis
why is grapefruit bad with cialis generic tadalafil 20mg india cialis hartproblemen
cialis flushing cialis generics is cialis viagra or levitra best
cialis bester preis tadalafil 5 mg genericos cialis contrareembolso
buy online viagra generic viagra rx viagra for men
make cialis more effective ratiopharm cialis 5mg dosierung
risque cialis generique tadalafil generic where to buy welches cialis
le vrai cialis warnings for tadalafil i need cialis
risco cialis tadalafil generic where to buy cialis online in uk
Lanoxin pharmacy without dr prescriptions safe canadian pharmacies
cialis online recensioni cialis dosing cialis cosa contiene
cialis healthy male tadalafil india 10 mg viagra cialis levitra pramil
cialis une fois par jour taldenafil cialis 5mg malaysia
cialis levitra generique how much is tadalafil 5mg medco cialis price
how is viagra different from cialis 80mg tadalafil cialis oglasnik
newport pharmaceuticals cialis taldenafil cialis marcumar
cialis online discreet cost of tadalafil 10mg cialis komentari
review on cialis taldenafil cialis generico recensioni
cialis online nl generic tadalafil 5mg price cialis genuine buy
cialis generico ecuador tadalafil generic date prijs cialis belgie
cialis generico bugiardino prescription tadalafil online what kind of doctor prescribes cialis
cialis feedback prescription tadalafil online cialis flagyl
cialis fast heartbeat cost of tadalafil 10mg onde encontrar cialis mais barato
cialis back pain cause tadalafil generic date cialis generika hersteller
generic viagra cialis online pharmacy how much is tadalafil cialis 5 prospecto
cialis blocked nose cialis cialis online pharmacy cialis domaine public
5 hour energy cialis tadalafil 10 mg coupon cialis professional new zealand
what does cialis used for tadalafil order online no prescription cialis produced in india
cialis dosierungen tadalafil generic where to buy online rx for cialis
does cialis cause impotence tadalafil india 10 mg bd cialis
will insurance pay for cialis for bph tadalafil india 10 mg preco cialis no brasil
cialis bruk tadalafil bnf cialis clonazepam
medikament cialis 5 mg where to order tadalafil tablets fake lilly cialis
cialis generique 5 mg online cheap tadalafil cialis rls
cialis vs licor best price usa tadalafil cialis drogasmil
cialis color of pills cialis generico cialis with klonopin
buy cialis in kuala lumpur side effects for tadalafil cialis nuspojave
health express cialis tadalafil prix cialis patong
how many hours is cialis effective tadalafil without a doctor prescription cialis pierde efectividad
natural products like cialis online cheap tadalafil buy cialis from usa
what is better levitra viagra or cialis tadalafil daily online cialis bestellen zonder recept
cialis preis italien tadalafil wiki cheap viagra cialis online
cialis brand uk tadalafil interactions cialis price increase
buying cialis in cambodia tadalafil prix cialis effective hours
cialis before going out tadalafil cost walmart prospect medicament cialis
viagra cialis czy levitra sildenafil vs tadalafil online pharmacy generic cialis
cialis dissolvable tadalafil vs sildenafil kortison cialis
cialis ed infarto sildenafil vs tadalafil kwikmed cialis coupon
cialis peptides best tadalafil generic megalis vs cialis
cialis zamienniki tadalafil alternative cialis gives me heartburn
cialis most effective sildenafil vs tadalafil cheap discount cialis
buy brand name cialis online tadalafila orthostatic hypotension cialis
whats best viagra cialis levitra online cheap tadalafil cialis 5 mg pharmacokinetics
buy cialis on craigslist tadalafil alternative review generic cialis
cialis balenia tadalafil online cialis drogasil
buy cialis from india tadalafil prix does kaiser cover cialis
breaking cialis pills in half tadalafil from canada to usa cialis costo monterrey
cialis lecce sildenafil vs tadalafil does viagra or cialis help premature ejaculation
cialis 50mg palsu tadalafil vs sildenafil maintenance dose cialis
cialis 5mg prices tadalafil daily online cialis effects on heart
buying cialis in malaysia tadalafil walmart vand cialis eagle
cialis istanbul tadalafil mylan cialis goes generic
discreet cialis tadalafil wiki best generic drugs cialis
headache with cialis tadalis sx tadalafil cialis foggia
cheap female cialis online tadalafil prix cialis in mississauga
vendo cialis zaragoza best tadalafil generic how does cialis cause back pain
cialis effects on pregnancy sildenafil medication cialis wskazania
viagra cialis diferencias best tadalafil generic viagra plus cialis
cialis over use tadalafil sandoz generic cialis nederland
cialis occhi rossi tadalafil uk prescription viagra vs cialis headaches
viagra cialis kokemuksia sildenafil medication caracteristicas cialis
cialis international pharmacy where to order tadalafil tablets cialis use for what
cialis frecuencia tadalafil vs sildenafil cialis usual dose
cialis efectos negativos gГ©nГ©rique tadalafil 36 hour cialis mg
lisinopril medicine
modafinil daily
buy ivermectin cream for humans
amoxicillin online no prescription
female cialis online buy cialis 5mg online uk buy cialis in ontario
cialis nih buy cialis daily use buy cialis online us pharmacy
cialis 5 ipb buy cialis kenya cialis puerto vallarta
cialis overnight fedex buy cialis in pune enkelttilskud cialis
best website for generic cialis buy cialis brisbane cialis price in uae
cialis product insert buy cialis 5 mg cialis etken maddesi nedir
cialis daily 2.5 mg cost
cialis 5mg efficace buy cialis in new zealand better results viagra or cialis
cialis 5mg coupon buy cialis in calgary effects of cialis on heart
cialis cause heartburn buy cialis greece generic cialis 5mg
generic cialis made in usa buy cialis eu cialis buy cheap online
cialis caracteristicas buy cialis in kl levitra oder viagra oder cialis
differences between cialis viagra levitra buy cialis for cheap from us pharmacy cialis jovem
uso prolongado cialis buy cialis in kuala lumpur euro pharma cialis
cialis online from us pharmacy buy cialis in jakarta cialis et maladie cardiaque
cialis bruise buy cialis in beijing cialis effetto ritardato
does cialis increase heart rate buy cialis daily uk does cialis cause hiccups
cialis dry eyes buy cialis for cheap from us pharmacy cialis costo colombia
cialis orange pill buy cialis in edmonton cialis creatine
cialis et reflux gastrique buy cialis in manila cialis pastilla chile
viagra brand
cialis buy overnight buy cialis jakarta grande pharmacie lyonnaise cialis
cialis et edex buy cialis california cialis for heart failure
best use of cialis buy cialis everyday heavy drinking with cialis
wer kennt cialis buy cialis 5mg online uk cialis libido boost
cialis pastilla generico buy cialis 5 mg uk cialis use in bodybuilding
clomid 50mg coupon
cialis internet bestellen buy cialis for cheap from us pharmacy cialis professional originale
cialis geciktirici midir buy cialis in germany viagra versus cialis cost
reliable online pharmacy cialis buy cialis 5mg cialis inventor
donde consigo cialis generico buy cialis in england cialis benefits prostate
cialis conceiving buy cialis in greece cialis preise ungarn
cialis most effective dose buy cialis calgary lilly cialis diario
cialis preise in holland buy cialis chennai do you like cialis
cialis 5mg prostatectomie buy cialis in new york cialis cutter
how much is cialis with insurance buy cialis in chiang mai medicament cialis 5
cialis generic in india buy cialis for cheap from us pharmacy female equivalent of cialis
cialis 5 mg heartburn buy cialis dubai cialis viagra which is better
what is cialis viagra buy cialis brisbane cialis pump
erectile dysfunction cialis viagra buy cialis everyday cialis figado
36 horas cialis buy cialis in brisbane order liquid cialis
cialis et libido buy cialis france use of cialis pills
generic cialis usa buy cialis 40 mg generic cialis gnc
medicament cialis effet buy cialis in ontario cialis cutter
cialis milanuncios buy cialis in edmonton best buy on cialis
how does cialis feel buy cialis bangkok buy female cialis pills
ivermectin 9mg
ivermectin purchase
indian cialis online buy cialis in bangkok beste potenzmittel cialis
stromectol tablets
cialis is used for what buy cialis brand online viagra cialis online bestellen
generic ivermectin cream
cost of cialis new zealand buy cialis in england cutting cialis 5 mg in half
welfil cialis buy cialis in bangkok pharmacy cialis chronic pelvic pain
cialis online in europe buy cialis lilly minimum effective dose cialis
cialis gimnasio buy cialis generic india cialis increased urination
stromectol 3 mg price
cialis 5 mg pret buy cialis from europe how does cialis help
ivermectin 3mg
cialis vs kaboom buy cialis in cyprus cialis vigour
ivermectin pills
cialis charakterystyka produktu buy cialis 40 mg online pharmacy cost cialis
stromectol coronavirus
ivermectin 4 mg
ivermectin online
cialis for everyday use cost buy cialis in indonesia cialis yeast infection
ivermectin rx
ivermectin for humans
cialis us online pharmacy buy cialis in ireland cialis purchase uk
contact cialis buy cialis ebay bijsluiter cialis 5
cialis maximum dose buy cialis brisbane eu uso cialis
drogaverde cialis buy cialis 36 hour cialis zararlari
how much is cialis in new zealand buy cialis in italy legit website for cialis
cialis holland bestellen buy cialis in phuket cialis validade
stromectol australia
buy ivermectin pills
cialis levitra diferencia buy cialis cheap canada generic cialis made in usa
diferencia cialis viagra cialis pills preiswerte cialis
cialis for everyday use cheap generic cialis canadian pharmacy chi produce cialis
how to buy stromectol
cheap cialis online usa cialis generic cialis for sale cialis oryginalne
cialis bph nhs tadalis sx tadalafil name for generic cialis
cialis dose vs viagra buy tadalafil cialis livraison 48h
viagra levitra cialis difference medshuku cheap cialis online viagra cialis ersatz
cheap cialis online europe tadalafil liquid cialis foglietto
40 mg cialis online tadalafil 5 mg buy 40 mg cialis
stromectol in canada
ivermectin 6
generic cialis in bangkok tadalafil 10 mg coupon cialis in prague
buy ivermectin
chi puo prescrivere cialis how much is tadalafil real cialis cheap
oral ivermectin cost
cialis increased urination buy cialis brand canada cialis kvinnor
cheapest online pharmacy for cialis cialis generic cialis online buy cialis in kenya
ivermectin 12 mg
cialis price usa order generic cialis online uk precision peptides cialis
cialis marokko tadalafil from india 5mg generic cialis levitra viagra
cialis generico rj medshuku cialis professional viagra cialis dosierung
ivermectin generic cream
cialis lust cialis super active plus cialis with ibuprofen
cialis femmes tadalafil warnings cialis erfarenheter
stromectol cost
cialis murcia buy brand cialis cheap will unitedhealthcare pay for cialis
ivermectin 200
ivermectin cream 5%
36 hour pill cialis le tadalafil cialis 5 mg prostate
cialis 5 mg giornaliero cialis cialis viagra etc
viagra vs cialis bluelight daily cialis buy cialis from online pharmacy
stromectol where to buy
stromectol where to buy
cost of cialis in nz cialis tablet cialis immagini
cost of ivermectin 1% cream
cialis bula 5 mg tadalafil liquid for sale cialis whirlpool
cialis jaw pain tadalafil 40 mg cialis 5 mg opiniones
pastillas cialis genericas cheap daily cialis online cialis or viagra online
buy stromectol pills
can you buy stromectol over the counter
cialis chewing gum cialis price priapism cialis
generic cialis from usa tadalafil sans ordonnance cialis rash cutaneo
cialis liver enzymes cialis dose cialis priser
ivermectin tablet 1mg
cost of cialis in india buy 5mg tadalafil cialis gegen hohen blutdruck
effective dose cialis medshuku cialis professional cialis valor
order cialis online mastercard best buy cialis online cialis einnahmemenge
buy ivermectin canada
cialis haplari canada cialis cialis preis in holland
cialis kimler kullanamaz cialis buy liquid cialis online
cialis levitra oder viagra buy brand cialis cheap best use of cialis
cialis 5 mg costco generic tadalafil 5mg price buy cialis online in nz
cialis epilepsy order cialis ritalin plus cialis
ivermectin cream canada cost
cialis meningen canadian cialis order why does cialis make my back hurt
cialis idade tadalafil sans ordonnance buy cialis legally online
buy cialis 5 mg uk medshuku how to get cialis cialis livraison urgente
ivermectin price uk
ivermectin generic
nuovo cialis generico where can i buy cialis online usa cialis legs pain
ivermectin 500mg
viagra cialis online bestellen cialis coupon is cialis effective for bph
cialis lilly confezioni cialis buy cialis online cialis viagra levitra pricing
stromectol drug
jual cialis murah online cialis viagra cialis lequel choisir
does pacific blue cross cover cialis canadian cialis order melange cialis et levitra
boites cialis cialis buy cialis insurance limits cialis
potenzmittel cialis preise cheap cialis canadian health insurance cialis
cialis preise ungarn tadalis sx tadalafil cialis erste mal
cialis congestive heart failure tadalafil uses cialis in your 30s
cialis contro impotenza canadian pharmacies cialis 40 mg opinioni
stromectol tablets
stromectol covid 19
price check cialis best cialis pill cialis c800
cialis prescricao medica order generic cialis online uk cialis hur mycket
ivermectin price usa
ivermectin cost in usa
cialis for breathing buy cialis cheap canada cialis mix viagra
cialis c20 opinie tadalafil cost in canada health insurance cialis
ivermectin 5 mg
cialis vision borrosa tadalafil 40 mg cialis prejudica gravidez
cialis em brasilia cialis online cialis insurance price
cialis effects on vision cialis tablet cialis cost bangkok
buy stromectol canada
review generic cialis warnings for tadalafil cialis oxido nitrico
ivermectin buy uk
cialis 3 dias canada online pharmacies purchase cialis in usa
ivermectin medicine
cost of stromectol medication
what class of drugs is cialis cialis blood pressure cialis increase vascularity
price of ivermectin
pagare cialis in contrassegno side effects of tadalafil coumadin vs cialis
ivermectin
buy cialis online overnight best buy cialis online difficulty ejaculating cialis
cialis in ecuador canadian pharmacy us tadalafil levitra viagra cialis cost
generic name for ivermectin
half cialis pill enough generic name buy cialis online in usa
does cialis give you heartburn buy cialis online openair cialis generique posologie
36 hour cialis parody buying cialis does cialis react with lisinopril
ivermectin online
cialis bestellen england canadian cialis order cialis drug prices
ivermectin over the counter
is cialis bad for your liver cialis tablets cialis effect on brain
viagra cialis levitra uk buy generic cialis with paypal cialis properties
buy stromectol pills
cialis double dose rx tadalafil tablets 10 mg cialis cuba
cialis controindicazioni emorroidi buy cialis from canada does cialis cause leg pain
does cialis cause dry eyes buy 5mg tadalafil best price on generic cialis
ivermectin 1%
cialis efeitos colaterais bula where to order tadalafil tablets cialis confidence booster
cialis varighet medshuku cialis without a doctor prescription cialis for prostate hypertrophy
stromectol 6 mg dosage
cialis 5mg prices can i buy cialis online safely pharmacy cost of cialis
difference entre viagra cialis levitra prices for cialis in canada posologia cialis 5mg
buying cialis online legit how much is tadalafil euroclinic cialis
price of ivermectin
ivermectin over the counter
medikament cialis generic tadalafil buy female cialis pills
cialis provoca diarrea cialis online purchase canada cialis did nothing
which is less expensive viagra or cialis cialis super active plus kebaikan cialis
generic stromectol
cialis mais barato no brasil tadalafil alternative cialis bulk
generic cialis uk how long does tadalafil last cialis una diaria
stromectol buy uk
getting cialis in bangkok best cialis pill costco cialis prices
cheapest generic cialis online buy cialis pills online cialis eczane izmir
efeitos colaterais viagra cialis buy cialis pills cialis kuala lumpur
cumpara cialis medshuku cialis professional cialis india generic
disulfiram medicine
cialis in ungarn buy cheap cialis online canada cialis uk cheap
cialis contact number how much does cialis cost cialis viagra levitra which is better
cialis brand coupon
canadian viagra online
tadalafil 20mg
cialis tablets uk
tadalafil from india – canadian healthcare cialis buy cialis 20mg uk
bitcoin pharmacy online – cialis pharmacy online discount on cialis
cialis 40mg online australia
cialis generic buy online
buy sildenafil online cheap
where can i buy cialis tadalafil in edmonton
finpecia 1 mg
generic cialis 5mg online
tadalafil canada generic over the counter
I’ve been surfing online more than three hours today, yet
I never found any interesting article like yours. It is
pretty worth enough for me. In my view, if all site owners and bloggers made good content
as you did, the internet will be a lot more useful than ever before.
wellbutrin pills
tadalafil 10mg australia
finpecia without prescription
order generic viagra from canada
canadian pharmacy antibiotics
buy cialis lowest price
tadalafil tablets prices tadalafil 20mg coupon is cialis safe
vardenafil 20 mg price directions for taking levitra levitra 20mg in india
buy sildenafil online australia
I think other website proprietors should take this website as an model, very clean and magnificent user friendly style and design, let alone the content. You’re an expert in this topic!
viagra australia sildenafil cost costco viagra prescription
buspar risks buspar info is buspirone
Greetings! Very helpful advice in this particular
article! It’s the little changes which will make the most significant changes.
Thanks a lot for sharing!
india pharmacy careprost careprost vs latisse reviews careprost vs bimat
Hi there just wanted to give you a quick heads up.
The text in your post seem to be running off the screen in Firefox.
I’m not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with web browser
compatibility but I figured I’d post to let you know. The style
and design look great though! Hope you get the issue resolved soon. Thanks
cefdinir suspension reconstituted omnicef medication generic cefdinir for uti dosing
I need to to thank you for this wonderful read!! I certainly loved every bit of it.
I’ve got you saved as a favorite to look at new things you
purchase sildenafil citrate – viagra soft gel capsules can you order viagra for woman
Its such as you read my mind! You appear to grasp so
much about this, such as you wrote the e book in it or something.
I think that you simply can do with a few p.c. to
power the message house a little bit, but other than that, this
is fantastic blog. An excellent read. I’ll definitely be back.
online viagra sales – buy viagra online with v online generic viagra
hydroxychloroquine 70 mg
legit mexican pharmacy
vardenafil vs tadalafil cialis average price cialis india price
Howdy would you mind letting me know which
hosting company you’re utilizing? I’ve loaded your blog in 3 different internet browsers and I must say
this blog loads a lot quicker then most. Can you
suggest a good internet hosting provider at a reasonable
price? Thanks, I appreciate it!
cialis patent cialis 10mg cost generic tadalafil australia
order viagra online viagra dosages goodrx viagra
can you buy sildenafil
One thing is always that one of the most popular incentives for making use of your card is a cash-back and also rebate provision. Generally, you’re going to get 1-5 back for various acquisitions. Depending on the card, you may get 1 again on most expenses, and 5 back on expenses made going to convenience stores, filling stations, grocery stores and ‘member merchants’.
vardenafil prices levitra 20mg in india vardenafil generic cost
I’ve been surfing online more than 2 hours today, yet I never found any
interesting article like yours. It’s pretty worth enough for me.
Personally, if all web owners and bloggers made good content as you did, the net
will be much more useful than ever before.
cialis 20mg dosage cialis 50mg generic 5mg cialis cost
Way cool! Some very valid points! I appreciate you writing this
post and also the rest of the site is extremely good.
price tadalafil 20mg
cheap cialis for daily use – cialis soft tabs 10mg tadalafil in mexico
finasteride canada pharmacy
sildenafil tabs 50mg
generic cialis 200mg
lilly cialis
cialis in mexico price – cialis online order order cialis 40mg
disulfiram tablets 250 mg price
generic cialis 60 mg india
how much for viagra
https://seo.analizsaita.online/en/domain/it.bitcoinforearnings.com
stromectol 3 mg tablet – ivermectin us ivermectin price comparison
drugstore com online pharmacy prescription drugs
where to purchase clomid
canadian pharmacy viagra 100mg
sildenafil for sale online
viagra best price canada
viagra pills for women
cialis pharmacy cost
stromectol usa
stromectol medication – cost of stromectol medication stromectol medicine
lexapro europe
https://bit.ly/gidonline-ok-google
casinos online – real casino gambling games
how to get viagra for women
https://bit.ly/films-ne-dshi-2 films
can you buy viagra over the counter australia
where can i buy hydroxychloroquine buy chloroquin
daily cialis cost
how can i get viagra without a prescription
buy viagra from canada
generic sildenafil in canada
online casino for real cash – online casino usa empire casino online
uk viagra buy
generic tadalafil coupon
https://disqus.com/by/laquitaposton/about/
buy tadalafil 20mg
https://bit.ly/films-ne-dshi-2 смотреть
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ Смотреть хороший фильм
impotence pills – the best ed pills what causes ed
reduslim compresse prezzo
where can you buy antabuse
essay writer reddit how to write a paper in apa format
purchase nolvadex no prescription
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK фильм смотреть
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW Смотреть фильмы 2021
https://bit.ly/37u6VuF смотреть фильм
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK фильм
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B смотреть фильм
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG films
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW онлайн просмотр
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B смотреть фильм
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ Смотреть интересное кино
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr смотреть онлайн
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P смотреть онлайн любимые фильмы и сериалы
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ смотреть
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr Смотреть крутое кино
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt Смотреть фильмы 2021
tadalafil cost in india
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG смотреть
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B смотреть онлайн
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B kino
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ смотреть
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG фильм
https://bit.ly/37u6VuF фильм смотреть
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr смотреть
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ Новые российские фильмы
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B Смотреть крутое кино
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B фильм
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr Новые фильмы
https://bit.ly/37u6VuF movies
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P кино
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ фильмы онлайн
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt Смотреть хороший фильм
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK Новые российские фильмы
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ онлайн просмотр
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P Список новых фильмов
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW смотреть онлайн любимые фильмы и сериалы
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ фильм онлайн
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr смотреть онлайн
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK фильм
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW Смотреть фильмы 2021
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P кино
https://bit.ly/37u6VuF смотреть
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr Смотреть фильмы 2021
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt смотреть
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG films
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt смотреть фильм
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW Фильмы которые стоит посмотреть
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK смотреть онлайн
https://bit.ly/37u6VuF онлайн просмотр
https://bit.ly/37u6VuF Смотреть фильмы онлайн
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW фильм
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG смотреть фильм
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG кино
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK Фильмы которые стоит посмотреть
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P Фильмы которые стоит посмотреть
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P Смотреть интересное кино
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P films
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG смотреть онлайн любимые фильмы и сериалы
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt фильм
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P смотреть фильм
tadalafil generic price in india
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt смотреть фильм
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ смотреть онлайн
best otc ed pills – buyedpl.com cheap erectile dysfunction pills
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK Смотреть хороший фильм
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P фильм
tadalafil professional
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ Смотреть хороший фильм
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG Новые фильмы
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW смотреть фильм
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B Смотреть фильмы 2021
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P Новые фильмы
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG Смотреть фильмы онлайн ютуб
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG онлайн просмотр
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK Смотреть фильмы 2021
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW смотреть фильм
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B Смотреть фильмы онлайн ютуб
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ смотреть
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P фильм онлайн
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK кино
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG фильм онлайн
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr Смотреть фильмы 2021
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr фильм
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt Смотреть крутое кино
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG фильмы онлайн
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr Новые фильмы
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P смотреть фильм
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ Список новых фильмов
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P смотреть онлайн
buy provigil in mexico
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P фильм онлайн
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ фильм смотреть
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW Смотреть фильмы онлайн ютуб
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P кино
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW смотреть фильм
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr Смотреть интересное кино
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B Смотреть интересное кино
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B movies
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt фильм онлайн
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ кино
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr Новые российские фильмы
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt фильмы онлайн
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG фильмы онлайн
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr Новые российские фильмы
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P смотреть фильм
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P фильм
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW Фильмы которые стоит посмотреть
prednisone online for sale – prednisone 40mg pills prednisone pack
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr Смотреть фильмы онлайн ютуб
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG kino
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr смотреть онлайн любимые фильмы и сериалы
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW фильм
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK Смотреть хороший фильм
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B Смотрите фильмы онлайн в хорошем качестве
Hello would you mind letting me know which webhost you’re
using? I’ve loaded your blog in 3 different internet browsers and I must say this blog loads a
lot faster then most. Can you recommend a good web hosting provider
at a fair price? Thanks a lot, I appreciate it!
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG Смотреть фильмы онлайн ютуб
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P онлайн просмотр
https://bit.ly/37u6VuF movies
viagra alternative gnc sildenafil side effects viagra in canada
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P movies
https://bit.ly/37u6VuF Смотреть фильмы онлайн ютуб
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW кино
I will right away seize your rss as I can not to find your email subscription hyperlink or newsletter
service. Do you have any? Kindly permit
me understand so that I may subscribe. Thanks.
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt смотреть фильм
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P фильм
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK фильм смотреть
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P фильм онлайн
tadalafil 20mg online canada
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK Смотреть хороший фильм
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt Смотреть фильмы онлайн
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt фильм
Greetings from Colorado! I’m bored to death at work so I decided to check out your site on my iphone during lunch break.
I really like the knowledge you provide here and can’t wait to take a
look when I get home. I’m surprised at how quick your blog loaded on my
cell phone .. I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyways, great blog!
https://bit.ly/37u6VuF фильм
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P кино
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK Смотреть крутое кино
flagyl dose oral metronidazole in cats flagyl dosage epocrates
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P смотреть онлайн
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK фильм
cialis super active cheap
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW смотреть фильм
I seriously love your site.. Pleasant colors & theme.
Did you build this web site yourself? Please
reply back as I’m wanting to create my own website and would
love to learn where you got this from or what the theme
is named. Cheers!
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P смотреть фильм
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P кино
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P онлайн просмотр
domperidone galactagogue domperidone 30 mg domperidone motility
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW Список новых фильмов
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt Смотреть фильмы онлайн
Hi there just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The words
in your article seem to be running off the screen in Safari.
I’m not sure if this is a format issue or something to do with browser compatibility but I thought I’d post to
let you know. The design and style look great though!
Hope you get the problem fixed soon. Thanks
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr Смотреть фильмы онлайн ютуб
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG Новые российские фильмы
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P Фильмы которые стоит посмотреть
https://bit.ly/37u6VuF films
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B Смотреть интересное кино
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ Новые фильмы
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B смотреть
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW Смотрите фильмы онлайн в хорошем качестве
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P кино
https://bit.ly/37u6VuF фильм
ivermectin pills
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr Смотрите фильмы онлайн в хорошем качестве
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt Смотреть хороший фильм
generic viagra paypal canada
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW фильм
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ Новые российские фильмы
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B фильм
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P онлайн фильм
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt фильмы онлайн
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt смотреть онлайн любимые фильмы и сериалы
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW смотреть
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK Новые российские фильмы
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B смотреть
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt фильм смотреть
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG смотреть
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P kino
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr Смотреть интересное кино
https://bit.ly/3Aj0jeW Смотреть интересное кино
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK фильм
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK Фильмы которые стоит посмотреть
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG смотреть онлайн
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr фильм
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ онлайн фильм
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P Смотреть хороший фильм
https://bit.ly/37u6VuF смотреть
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ films
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ фильм смотреть
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B Смотреть фильмы онлайн
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P смотреть фильм
https://bit.ly/37u6VuF кино
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B Смотреть хороший фильм
https://bit.ly/3Cyourt онлайн просмотр
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK Смотреть крутое кино
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr смотреть онлайн
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK онлайн просмотр
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P смотреть онлайн
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr смотреть онлайн
buy generic tadalafil 20 mg from india
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK кино
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK онлайн просмотр
https://bit.ly/3yBOvDZ kino
https://bit.ly/3jDttyG Новые фильмы
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B kino
https://bit.ly/3fP2TBr онлайн просмотр
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P онлайн просмотр
https://bit.ly/3yOEYJK фильм смотреть
https://bit.ly/37u6VuF movies
https://bit.ly/3yzht7B смотреть онлайн любимые фильмы и сериалы
https://bit.ly/37xtT3P фильм